top of page
logo

Publication Success or Rejection

brutonj60
Jul 1
4 min read

Updated: Oct 7

Writing a scientific manuscript is a significant milestone, but your manuscript draft is not the endpoint. You want your work to be read and make an impact. Thus, the draft must be transformed into a gripping story. This post guides you through the essential steps of refining your scientific article and enhancing its overall quality.


Close-up view of a stack of scientific journals on a wooden table
Who reads scientific journals in the library? Who reads badly written science?

Understanding the Importance of Clarity and Precision


In scientific writing, clarity and precision are paramount. Readers should easily grasp your research findings without wading through jargon or convoluted sentences. Here are some strategies to enhance clarity:


  • Use Simple Language: Avoid complex words. Instead of saying "utilize," simply say "use."

  • Be Concise: Eliminate unnecessary words. For instance, instead of saying "these novel findings show that," just say "our findings indicate that."

  • Define Technical Terms: If you use new terminology, define it for the reader.


Structuring Your Article Effectively


A good article guides readers through your research effortlessly. Below is a common structure that can be used:


Title


An informative title is best to highlight the main finding or focus. For example, instead of "Methods to ameliorate obesity-induced cardiovascular disease," consider "Moderate exercise and reduced fat intake reduce hypertension, heart attacks but not strokes"


Abstract


The abstract summarizes the entire article. It should include:


  • Purpose: What was the primary aim?

  • Methods: Clearly describe the methods, and split into one section for one method

  • Results: Summarize the key findings.

  • Conclusion: What are is the implication of the results?


Introduction


This gives the background information and justifies why your research was necessary. Clearly outline the research question and objectives.


Methods


Describe the methodology used in your study. The details in this section should be enough to let other researchers to replicate your results. Include:


  • Subjects: Detail age, sex, coexisting morbidity

  • Materials: What techniques were used? Were blood/urine/tissue samples used?

  • Procedure: Describe the biochemical techniques used to obtain data.

  • Statistics: How were the data analysed?


Results


Describe your findings conscisely. Use figures to show key data. Ensure that each figure has an accurate legend. Tables are hard to read and are used only if absolutely necessary.


Discussion


Start this section by sumarising in no more than two sentences what you major results are. Discuss how they differ from previous research and what new information they add. You must describe possible limitations of your study (this is a frequent complaint from referees that authors fail to see any limitation). Finally, desribe the implications of your finding for future research in the area.


Conclusion


Summarize the main findings of the research and its significance for future research.


Enhancing Readability


To improve the readability of your article, consider the following tips:


  • Use Headings and Subheadings: Break the text into short sections to help the reader.

  • Short Paragraphs: Write short sentences. Keep the paragraphs short, ideally no more than five sentences.


Citing Sources Properly


Proper citation is crucial in scientific writing. It gives credit to original authors and allows readers to locate your sources. Familiarize yourself with the citation style required by the journal you are submitting to, whether it’s APA, MLA, or another format.


Most Common Citation Styles


  • APA: Often used in psychology and care sciences.

  • Vancouver system: Frequently used in medicine and bimomedical sciences.


Get Feedback from Colleagues


This is important . It is better to hear harsh and helpful comments from you colleagues than from an editor . Colleagues can catch errors you might have missed and may provide valuable insights/interpretations.


Preparing for Submission


Once you think your article is ready, prepare for submission. Follow these steps:


  1. Review Submission Guidelines: Read the instructions completely and carefully. Each journal has specific requirements regarding formatting, length, and style. Unless you are highly esteemed in the academic world, stick to the instructions.

  2. Prepare Supplementary Materials: Do you need to submit original data? Do you need a cover letter or conflict of interest statement?

  3. Double-Check References: Ensure all citations are correct and that superscripts and subscripts are correctly inserted..


Navigating the Peer Review Process


After submission, your article will undergo peer review. This process can be depressing, both for you and the reviewers but it is essential for maintaining scientific integrity. This is the typical sequence but timelines can vary from four weeks to many months:


  • Reviewer Feedback: Reviewers point out shortfalls and suggest how these might be answered. You must address their concerns and make revisions accordingly.

  • Revisions: Respond to feedback politely. If you disagree with a reviewer’s comment, give clear reasons for your stance.

  • Resubmission: Resubmit your article after making all the revisions required. In your response letter, describe if you have made all of the changes or only some of the changes requsted. It is best to copy and paste the reviewer's comments and then write your response underneath each comment.


Dealing with Rejection


Rejection is not uncommon. This is how to handle it:


  • Relax: Put the manuscript in a drawer for two to three days.

  • Read the review again: Analyze the reviewers’ comments. Can you do new experiments or a new analysis that that answers their concerns?

  • Revise and Resubmit: Revise thoroughly and submit to another journal.



Conclusion


Polishing your scientific article for publication is never simple. It needs attention to detail and a structured approach. Remember, your goal is to explain your research to the world.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page